

Old Mutual Insure
Based on recent customer reviews, Old Mutual Insure delivers an overwhelmingly positive agent experience, with customers consistently naming individual consultants who go above and beyond. However, a sharp contrast emerges in claims handling, where delays, poor communication during claims, and disputed rejections cause significant frustration. Pricing transparency also draws concern, particularly around under-insurance disputes and unexplained premium changes.
Replied to 100% of negative reviews
Reply time on negative reviews: 9h 43m
TrustIndex
10
Perfect Score
Ranking
#4
in Home Insurance
Reply Time
6h 59m
NPS Score
51
Recommended: Very Likely
Replied to 100% of negative reviews
Reply time on negative reviews: 9h 43m
Jul '25 - Jun '26
Based on recent customer reviews, Old Mutual Insure delivers an overwhelmingly positive agent experience, with customers consistently naming individual consultants who go above and beyond. However, a sharp contrast emerges in claims handling, where delays, poor communication during claims, and disputed rejections cause significant frustration. Pricing transparency also draws concern, particularly around under-insurance disputes and unexplained premium changes.
Old Mutual Insure's biggest strength, according to Hellopeter's AI analysis, is Agent Quality & Customer Care. Customers consistently name specific agents like Lisa Joubert, Angel Zwane, Karabo Manaka, and Nkosinathi Msimanga as exceptional. Words like 'amazing,' 'asset,' and 'above and beyond' appear frequently across hundreds of reviews.
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Share Your Experience1 reviews | Active since Jan 2020
Lisa I had a great experience with Lisa from Old Mutual. She was kind, professional, and really went out of her way to help me understand my claim. Thank you Lisa!
The most common complaint about Old Mutual Insure, based on Hellopeter's AI analysis of recent customer reviews, is Claims Handling & Resolution. Customers report claims taking months with minimal updates, rejected claims citing under-insurance or maintenance exclusions, and SIU investigations that feel adversarial. Several reviewers threaten Ombudsman escalation.
Old Mutual Insure scores 3.5 out of 5 on Hellopeter's AI analysis of service quality in Insurance, compared to the Insurance industry average of 3. Their strongest theme is Agent Quality (4.7); their weakest is Claims Handling (2.6). The top AI-rated Insurance business on Hellopeter is Old Mutual Insure (4.7). How is the AI Score calculated? →
Old Mutual Insure has a TrustIndex of 10 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 3,989 reviews in the last 12 months. They reply to 100% of negative reviews, typically within 9 hours 43 min. Hellopeter has tracked Old Mutual Insure across 10,902 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →